Thursday, June 3, 2010

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo ***1/2

Director: Niels Arden Oplev
Cast: Noomi Rapace, Michael Nyqvist,
Sven-Bertil Taube, Peter Haber, Marika Lagercrant
Lena Endre, Björn Granat, Peter Andersson

A lesson in how to make a thriller, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo is the first entry in the film versions of the late Stieg Larsson's Millennium novels.
Remaining faithful to its paperback spirit, it relentlessly tries to turn each scene into the equivalent of an addictive page turner; therefore, it has a familiar structure, accumulating cliffhangers and a climax that makes sure you end up craving more.
Its twisty, noir inspired, plot finds its inspiration in the likeliest of sources: the teaming of the odd couple.
In this case it's Mikael Blomkvist (Nyqvist) and Lisbeth Salander (Rapace). Blomkvist is a disgraced financial journalist who has just been sentenced to three months in jail after a scandalous libel suit involving a prominent industrialist (Stefan Sauk).
Salander is an introverted, goth, twenty something who specializes in hacking computers, hi-tech investigation and beating the crap out of people who abuse her (including her legal guardian played with disgusting sexual hunger by the sinister Andersson).
When Blomkvist is hired by octogenarian millionaire Henrik Vanger (Taube) to investigate the mysterious disappearance of his niece Harriet, more than forty years before, he acquires an essential ally in Lisbeth.
How they meet is both part of the film's tendency to pull aces out of its sleeve and also one of its most fascinating propositions; for it wonders how much fate and determination have to do with this particular genre.
In the way the two main characters seem to reach out to each other, we are left trying to make sense about the way we influence our own perception.
Choices therefore are an essential part of the plot, "we choose who we are" exclaims Lisbeth as Mikael tries to understand her actions.
Yet this seemingly simple statement captures the major theme explored in the movie which is the primal human need to find itself by revisiting its history.
Instead of running away from things that have hurt them Mikael and Lisbeth appear to be drawn to the perpetuation of painful patterns.
Mikael hesitates for merely a second when asked by Vanger to take on a potentially dangerous case; is it his need to satiate his journalistic hunger with a good story or is he still unaware that his work can directly affect his life?
Lisbeth too is pulled by the force of Harriet's disappearance despite the eventual realization that she might be running into some of her own life experiences in the hellish process.
Is the author trying to give them catharsis by all means or does this path reek of masochism? If so can catharsis be related to masochism?
What results so compelling about the movie is that the central mystery they're trying to solve is half as intriguing as the mystery of who Mikael and Lisbeth are.
And considering that Harriet's disappearance is connected to Nazis, rape revenge, dark family traditions, corruption and fake evidence, you can imagine just how mysterious the people investigating it must be.
The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo owes itself mostly to the power of its great actors. Nyqvist is perfect as Mikael. His strange handsomeness contributes highly to make him likable in a way you just can't understand at first.
Full of self love, determination and an overcoming passion for his job he's the ultimate middle aged man.
Rapace's Lisbeth is an enigmatic creature made more appealing by her unconventional heroine qualities. Far from being an angel, she uses her own personal experiences to seek what might be an ultimate revenge on the men who wrong her (the Swedish title of the film is Men Who Hate Women) but more than a postmodern take on the action hero, Rapace makes Lisbeth someone completely human.
Her character is a complex hybrid of female empowerment and male fantasy. On one hand she's a rebel violent woman who takes justice on her own hands and has no problem going to bed with men or women.
The way she gets sex with Mikael out of the way halfway through the running time is a darkly funny moment in which the movie affirms to us that it has no concern for maintaining sexual tension...there are more important things to deal with here.
Yet Lisbeth is also an exciting male dream; the kick-ass woman who doesn't make a big deal out of sex and fulfills every cliché adolescent male dream.
How does Lisbeth reach a compromise between female identity and male fantasy is testament to Rapace's talents.
An incredibly exciting, if not entirely original thriller (there's not an overlapping of text, music and images montage it can resist) The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo thrives in its ability to find new joys in traditional structures, with its moody cinematography, iconic star making performances and inventive direction it dares you not to feel refreshed by its familiarity.


Burning Reels said...

I know very little of this series. Are you for or against the remake idea?

And speaking of directors linked with this, I don't get Fincher - he continues his dark path with the brilliant Zodiac and then makes the fluffy Benjamin Button and now The Social Network. Play to your strengths David!

Jose said...

As far as my understanding goes, the American version will take lots of liberties, for as not to be called a remake.

But I don't really think it's a good idea, especially because of what the actors in this series have done with the characters.

I would never be able to think of Carey Mulligan as Lisbeth Salander after watching the brilliant work of Noomi Rapace. Not only that, I don't think any current actress has the ability to pull off what Rapace does, at least not working under a Hollywood studio.

As for Fincher he must be going through a midlife crisis or in desperate need of an Oscar.

Oh and you should really seek these movies out, you're in Europe after all right?

Luke said...

Hmmm... I'm not sure what happened, but for some reason the comment I posted didn't actually work - but just so's you know, I said something along the lines of how long it has been since I've seen a rating this high at your blog, my friend, so this movie must be pretty excellent. To a discerning mind like yours, 3.5 stars is high praise indeed!

Jose said...

I'm sorry about the evil post eating Blogger Luke.
It's the intention that counts anyway.
Also, yes, I highly recommend this movie , you know I'm very picky lol. Only one movie (out of four) in English has managed 3.5 from me so far this year.

Runs Like A Gay said...

I was very disappointed by TGWTDT when I saw it. Yes, it was a moody modern thriller with an interesting twist with it's protagonists, but the main investigation was dull and without any clues.

How did we find the killer? Because he/she decided to kill the hero!

I also was very disappointed with the subtitles on the UK version. When the subtitling is done well the language is still rich, absorbing and captures the poetry and rhythm of the images. See Let The Right One in or Cyrano de Bergerac. In the UK release they were clunky and ultimately off putting. It's enough to make you learn Swedish.

Jose said...

Runs: I know what you mean about the main investigation it was very by the numbers (complete with the over explaining and everything) but the dynamics of the main characters with the investigation was what I loved so much.

That's too bad about the subtitling, the one I saw was rather good.

Rosibel said...

Hello Jose: I have been reading your blog for a while now and I love it! I read all 3 books before watching all 3 movies. The books are the best I read the first one in 6 days! obviously there are parts of the books that were not included but still they made a good addaptation.I agree with you on the excellent choice of the actors nobody would´ve done a better job.
te mando un abrazote enorme and you must come to buenos aires!

movie downloads said...

I find this post useful. Thanks for sharing. I would love to tell about it to my friends as well...Have a nice day !

New Film Trailers said...

Know more about Anna Gabriel, daughter of legendary rock star Peter Gabriel and director of Growing Up On Tour: A Family Portrait only at

Online Clothes Shopping said...

This is some valuable information. I would like to see more of such posts coming in the future.